merchant account

An organized system to handle payroll activities is a crucial element of any business that has employees. Payroll encompasses a variety of components that your company must handle accurately and promptly. Just as there are many moving parts to payroll, there are as many mistakes people often make when managing payroll. MagicPay Merchant Services lists six of the most common errors.

1. Inaccurate Employee Information

Keeping accurate paperwork is an essential part of the payroll process. People often mismatch Social Security numbers and employee names, an issue that happens so frequently that the Social Security Administration offers a free verification service so employers can check their data against SSA records. Other information that may be recorded incorrectly include exemptions or the number of deductions on an employee’s W-9. Also note that your obligation is not only to keep accurate records, but also to keep them secure.

2. Incomplete or Sloppy Pay Records

Employers must keep a minimum of three years of detailed pay records. Reports need to include payment rates, hours worked and payroll dates. Many states have additional record-keeping requirements, so it is vital to know the regulations in your location. If your data is not in order or you are missing records, you could run into problems in the future.

3. Missing Tax Deposit Deadlines

Filing taxes for a business can be confusing and time consuming. However, it is critical to know and meet IRS deadlines. If you are late or make an incorrect payment, you may incur costly penalties. Create a calendar of scheduled deadlines and plan time to prepare, file and deposit your payroll taxes.

4. Making Errors With Reporting

State policies change often, and the person who handles your payroll system must keep up with new requirements. Many payroll mistakes result from not having adequate or correct information. Maintaining accurate data and running timely reports is a necessity for your business success. If you can run reliable reports, you can catch errors before you process payroll.

5. Miscalculating Pay

According to a survey by the Workforce Institute, over half of the U.S. workforce has encountered a problem with their paychecks. These mistakes include non-payments, over-payments, late pay and inaccurate payment amounts. Errors related to your employees’ paychecks frustrate your staff and result in a lack of trust. Staff members may file lawsuits against you, depending on the situation. Incorrect payments could stem from many issues, such as misclassifying employees (see below), incorrectly calculating overtime, inaccurate pay rate and more.

6. Misclassifying Employees

Accurately reporting payroll data for tax purposes requires correctly classifying everyone working for you. As NOLN explains, the classification determines protections, benefits, minimum wage and overtime pay rates. Employee classifications include exempt and nonexempt, within which are regular full-time and part-time, and temporary (contract) full-time and part-time. Another classification is for independent contractors, which are non-employee freelancers. Mistakes in this data can deny employees wages and benefits and miscalculate tax amounts as well.

The Benefits of an Online Payroll Service

One way to ensure your tools for accounting (payroll, reporting, taxes and payments) are accurate is to use an online payroll service. Utilizing a program that works together with your current operation helps you minimize errors and save time. Auto payroll features reduce the amount of time you must spend on your payroll each week. This service requires an initial setup process, but you can devote your time to other areas of your company once you program it.

Payroll is a crucial aspect of your company’s success. It affects the morale of your team, your financial stability and your business reputation. Professional payroll services play a vital role in keeping your records organized and accurate to foster the success of your organization.

Efficient management of payroll systems should be a top priority for your business. Keeping track of deadlines, ensuring accurate data, running reports and analyzing for errors is time-consuming and requires meticulous planning and attention to detail. Professional payroll services have the systems in place to handle your needs so you avoid costly mistakes.

Looking for solid and reliable merchant services and credit card processing? Let MagicPay Merchant Services be your payment processing solution for your business. Find out more today! 855-891-2600

Written by Elena Stewart

Related Posts

View All
Payment Gateway in Puerto Rico Guide to Accepting Online Payments
Blog September 18, 2026

Payment Gateway in Puerto Rico: Guide to Accepting Online Payments

Guide to online payment gateways, payment platforms, and virtual terminals in Puerto Rico. Learn how to securely accept online card payments.

Seamless Payments for Educational Institutions
Blog September 17, 2026

Seamless Payments for Educational Institutions

Streamline payments for educational institutions with online billing, recurring payments, a virtual terminal, and centralized reports for administrative staff.

Wireless Terminals in Puerto Rico: POS Terminal Guide for Businesses
Blog September 17, 2026

Wireless Terminals in Puerto Rico: POS Terminal Guide for Businesses

Guide to Wireless Terminals and Wireless POS Systems in Puerto Rico: Dejavoo P3, P8, Clover Flex, and Go. Card payments and contactless payments for your business.

We’d love to hear from you

Let's talk

Contact Info

Customer Service Phone Directory

Hours of Operation:
24/7 Customer Service
Sales:
Sunday – Thursday: 24 Hrs
Friday: Closing at 4:00 PM EST
Saturday: Closed

Where Should I Call for Service?

Using the short questionnaire below, you will find the correct phone number to call for assistance.

For sales, upgrades or additional services please call 855-891-2600 ext 1.

Or email us at info@MagicPay.net

Or, click here to fill out our contact form and one of our representatives will contact you within 24 hours.

BankCard USA Customer Service / Technical Support

During regular business hours (M-F 10:00AM-8:00PM EST) - 800-589-8200

After hours:

First Data (MID starts with 4195) please call 888-339-0674.

FDR (MID starts with 5349) please call 866-597-5721.

TSYS (MID starts with 8867) please call 800-552-8227.

Blackstone

Customer Service / Technical Support: 305-718-6520 or 305-639-9590

Clover Support (VI & PR): 844-864-5449

Clover Support (US): 855-853-8340

First Data Support: 800-858-1166

Choice Merchant Solutions

Customer Service / Technical Support: 800-539-9116

Elavon

Customer Service / Technical Support: 800-819-6019 x1

Elavon - Activation: 866-451-4007 x4

Electronic Merchant Systems

Client Services: 800-615-1330

Group ISO

During regular business hours (M-F 10:00am - 9:00pm) - 800-410-4476

After hours: 800-228-0210

Maverick BankCard

Customer Service / Technical Support: 800-464-9777

NetPay BankCard

Customer Service / Technical Support: 800-366-1841

Signature Card Services

Regular Business Hours (M-F 10:30AM - 9:00PM EST): 800-631-3072 

After Hours:

If your MID starts with "4":

Customer Service / Technical Support: 800-228-0210

Voice Authorization: 800-228-1122

If your MID starts with "8":

Customer Service / Technical Support 800-622-2315

Voice Authorization: 800-944-1111

Switch Commerce / Sage

877-550-1310

Total Merchant Services (USA)

888-848-6825

Total Merchant Services (CA)

855-839-7280

Volt Merchant Solutions

Customer Service / Technical Support: 877-232-8503

Operator

If you do not know who is your merchant account provider please call our operator or email our support team to locate your account and direct you to the right phone number to call.

Diall 855-891-2600, EXT 0.

Email: info@MagicPay.net - make sure your business name is in the subject line.

MagicPay Payment Gateway

For training, billing and basic gateway questions: 855-891-2600 EXT 3.

For integration and higher level technical support: 800-617-4850.

Forgot Your Password?

Call either number above, or, for after hours, please send an email to info@MagicPay.net and one of our representatives will reset your password and send you a new password creation link.

In your email please include your name, business name, username for gateway and phone number.

Authorize.Net

866-682-4131

eProcessing Network

800-971-0997

USAePay

866-872-3729

Contact us